orgasmicyogurt asked: Would you agree Gothic is kind of the same as classic?
What a good question! The answer is a definite and resounding “no”, but there is a lot of intersection! For instance, just scrolling down the tracked tags “Gothic Lolita” and “Classic Lolita”, one can see good examples.
For instance, http://dailylolita.tumblr.com/post/13814915603/omenaruusu-reminding-us-that-less-really-can-be.
Also, http://croixdememoire.tumblr.com/post/13692306259 is an example of two coordinates that could be either Gothic or Classic, or as I like to say “Gothic Classic” (or “Classic Gothic”, whatever).
There is a lot of range within the confluence of these two styles (for instance, http://herajika.tumblr.com/post/13799968561/a-classic-lolita-outfit-from-a-few-weeks-ago is a good example of Classic Gothic that leans more towards Classic, but still has a few striking aspects that lend a solid Gothic feel to the outfit; and http://chasingcrowns.tumblr.com/post/13905778254 is an example of an outfit that is more Gothic, but still has many aspects of true Classic Lolita).
However, there are definitely outfits that are Classic and not at all recognizably Gothic (http://fannyrosie.tumblr.com/post/13808871346/brown-outfit-to-go-shopping-with-my-sister, for example) and outfits that are obviously Gothic (http://dailylolita.tumblr.com/post/8663083092/clefdemoname-in-gothic)
But as I said before, there is a lot of intersection, and there are especially a lot of element in Gothic Lolita that would qualify an outfit for Classic Style, and many Classic outfits would be perfect Gothic outfits if they were only in a black or other Gothic color (dark red, Moitie blue, etc.).
However, the same can be said of Sweet Lolita, Mori Girl, Dolly Kei, and many other fashion styles, because both Classic and Gothic Lolita have the widest ranges of possible styles of any of the substyles of Lolita (at least to my eye), so they are bound to meet in the middle!